Owen Carter

What you say to pupils matters - a lot

If there’s one thing I learnt from Growing Excellence, it’s that what you say to pupils matters. It really matters. Why?

It’s what takes you from this butterfly:

Austin's butterfly first draft

To this butterfly:

Austin's butterfly final draft Put simply, Dweck’s research shows us that often we get back what we put in. If you tell someone they’re excellent at English, this instils the belief that what matters is their inherent ability, not their effort. Good feedback should motivate further work, not put an end to it.

What does good feedback look like?

We asked Chris Hildrew of Chew Valley School for his tips on implementing high-impact feedback: [vimeo 114668267 w=500 h=281] What does Chris tell us? Specificity is king. Focus on the sentence as much as the essay. Kindness and helpfulness are also crucial. If you signpost the steps to improve it becomes much easier for the student to take them. If using peer feedback, it’s crucial to teach your pupils to keep the problem apart from the person – criticise the former, not the latter. These values seem like common sense. Yet how many times have you spoken to the whole class about something only a few got wrong (as one teacher’s pupil complains)? These small improvements pave the way for larger ones. That's the foundation of marginal learning gains, which I spoke to Zoe Elder about recently. That’s why you can’t say it too often: focus on the specifics, be constructive and be kind. That could be a motto for good teaching as well.

 

Subscribe to Optimus Education's Blog

Join other educators and get the latest Optimus blogs direct to your inbox.
Your data is safe with us: Privacy Policy

Similar Posts

Robert Slavin

Leave no pupils behind: the principles (and limits) of a mastery approach

If all pupils are to master the prerequisite skills for important lessons, teachers must have the resources to help them reach the same baseline. When giving a lesson, all teachers face a dilemma. Some pupils will master all the lesson content, some will learn it partially and others will not learn...
Read more...
Rebecca Carver

Helping all pupils to master maths

Primary teacher Rebecca Carver explains how combining a mastery approach with creative strategies can help all pupils to succeed in this often problematic subject. Using the Mathematics Mastery approach, we set the same learning objectives for every child in every lesson. All children get the same...
Read more...
Diane Wilson

Igniting a passion for science with technology

How can teachers ensure that able children are excited by science and appropriately challenged in ways that are motivating and rewarding? Go straight to How we identify gifted science learners Seeing science in action Challenge and real-life application Linking with experts and industry Pupil...
Read more...